The Plot Against America premiered in 2020 as a limited television series on HBO, adapted from Philip Roth's acclaimed novel of the same name. Upon its release, the show received critical praise for its timely exploration of political themes, strong performances—particularly from Winona Ryder as Evelyn Finkel and John Turturro as Rabbi Lionel Bengelsdorf—and its chilling alternate history narrative. Critics lauded the series' atmospheric tension and its poignant portrayal of a Jewish family confronting the rise of fascism in America. Over time, The Plot Against America has maintained a positive reputation, often cited as a thought-provoking piece that resonates with contemporary issues. While it may not have reached the mass appeal required to become a mainstream hit, it is appreciated by a dedicated audience and is often regarded as an underrated gem rather than a cult classic or dated relic.
Main Cast of The Plot Against America
Winona Ryder
Evelyn Finkel
In 'The Plot Against America,' Winona Ryder portrays Evelyn Finkel, a mother and wife navigating the rise of fascism in an alternate-history America. This role stands out in her career as it combines her strengths in portraying complex, nuanced characters with a mature emotional depth honed over years of acting. Unlike her earlier iconic roles in films like '
Beetlejuice' or '
Edward Scissorhands,' which leaned into fantasy and quirky youthfulness, Ryder's performance here is grounded in historical drama and intense family dynamics. This role highlights her evolution as an actress, showcasing her ability to convey resilience and vulnerability amidst political turmoil, thereby enriching her already diverse body of work.
John Turturro
Rabbi Lionel Bengelsdorf
John Turturro played a pivotal role in the TV miniseries 'The Plot Against America,' portraying Herman Levin, the patriarch of the Levin family navigating a dystopian alternate history. His nuanced performance was widely praised for its depth and emotional resonance, capturing the complex dynamics of a family under political and social strain. What made Turturro's portrayal unique was his ability to embody resilience and vulnerability simultaneously, bringing a relatable human element to a tense, politically charged narrative. A lesser-known fact about his involvement is that during filming, Turturro insisted on extensively studying the era's cultural and political climate to authentically represent his character's internal conflicts, often discussing these findings with the director to enhance the storytelling.
Zoe Kazan
Bess Finkel
Fans of Zoe Kazan would appreciate her role in the TV series "The Plot Against America" for its depth and complexity, showcasing her ability to portray nuanced emotions against a historical backdrop. This performance contrasts with her most iconic role in "
Ruby Sparks," where she played a whimsical and imaginative character. In "The Plot Against America," Kazan's character navigates the challenges of a reimagined America under different political leadership, providing a more dramatic and politically charged role compared to the romantic fantasy of "Ruby Sparks." An interesting detail is that Kazan's character in the series is partly inspired by real historical figures, adding authenticity to her portrayal and connecting personal family narratives to broader historical themes.
Morgan Spector
Herman Levin
Morgan Spector delivers a compelling performance as Herman Levin in 'The Plot Against America,' bringing depth and nuance to the role of a resilient Jewish father navigating the turbulent political climate of an alternate 1940s America. His portrayal stands out for its emotional authenticity and subtle strength, distinguishing itself from his more intense roles in productions like '
Homeland' and 'Manhattan.' A trivia fact about Spector is that he is married to actress Jessica Hecht, who also appears in 'The Plot Against America,' adding a layer of genuine chemistry to their on-screen characters.
Anthony Boyle
Alvin Levin
Anthony Boyle played the role of Alvin Levin in the TV miniseries 'The Plot Against America.' This character is central to the story's exploration of a family's experience during an alternate history America, marked by political upheaval and rising anti-Semitism. Boyle's performance in this series showcased his ability to convey nuanced emotional depth and contribute to a tense, immersive narrative. Compared to his earlier, more widely recognized work such as his breakthrough role as Scorpius Malfoy in the stage play 'Harry Potter and the Cursed Child,' this television role allowed him to transition confidently into screen acting and demonstrate versatility beyond theatre. 'The Plot Against America' marked a significant step in Boyle's career, highlighting his adaptability and expanding his presence in television drama, setting it apart from his previous roles primarily associated with stage performances.
Azhy Robertson
Philip Levin
Azhy Robertson played a pivotal role in the television series 'The Plot Against America,' where his performance was widely praised for its depth and emotional resonance. What made his portrayal unique was his ability to convey complex emotions with subtlety, bringing a profound sense of innocence and vulnerability to his character amid the show's tense, alternate historical backdrop. A lesser-known fact about his involvement is that Robertson spent considerable time studying historical footage and family stories to authentically capture the era's mood, demonstrating a level of dedication that impressed both the cast and crew.
Caleb Malis
Sandy Levin
Crew of The Plot Against America
Full backstage crew list →