Meet the cast of The Perfect Neighbor

"The Perfect Neighbor" is a gripping documentary that dives deep into a real-life tragedy fueled by fear, prejudice, and contentious Stand Your Ground laws. What makes it compelling is its raw and unfiltered use of police bodycam footage, providing an immersive and haunting perspective on how an ordinary neighborhood dispute escalated to a fatal confrontation. The documentary expertly balances emotional storytelling with a critical look at social and legal issues, offering viewers a profound and thought-provoking experience. Its candid performances by those involved, coupled with stark visuals, make the events come alive in an unsettling yet necessary way. This film is best suited for viewers interested in true crime, social justice, and those wanting to explore the complexities of community tensions and self-defense legislation.

Critics' Reviews

The film, directed by Geeta Gandbhir, is composed entirely from pre-existing footage—phone cameras, security tapes, and most notably, police body cameras. Gandbhir places the audience directly in the neighborhood, and we see firsthand how loving and kind the community is. Parents watch each other’s kids. Everyone knows everyone else. Both the parents and police officers remark on how glad they are that the kids are playing and enjoying their childhood instead of getting into trouble. Whenever Susan is not onscreen, everyone is more at ease. Even the interactions between the residents and the police officers are peaceful, as the body cam footage reveals how much the officers wish she would stop calling them. But dread builds month after month, as Susan keeps making calls, terrorizing her young neighbors. By the time tragedy occurs, everyone seems visibly beaten down by the senselessness of it all.

Full review