"The Cross" was released with moderate expectations and garnered a mixed reception from critics and audiences alike. Initially, some praised its atmospheric portrayal of a small Floridian fishing town and the emotional depth of the strained relationship between brothers Ray and Paul. However, others found its pacing slow and storytelling conventional, which led to it slipping under the radar of mainstream audiences.
Over time, "The Cross" has developed a more favorable reputation, especially among fans of character-driven dramas. Its nuanced exploration of grief, familial bonds, and personal conflict has resonated with a dedicated audience. While it may not be widely known, it is now regarded as an underrated gem that offers a poignant and intimate cinematic experience beyond its initial modest impact.