Meet the Cast of Shelby Oaks Movie

In the upcoming thriller "Shelby Oaks," viewers are introduced to a team of paranormal investigators known as the Paranormal Paranoids. At the heart of the story is Mia, portrayed by Camille Sullivan, who is grappling with the unsolved mystery of her sister Riley's disappearance. Twelve years have passed since the day Riley, the lead investigator of the group, vanished without a trace during one of their investigations. Mia embarks on a heart-wrenching journey to uncover the truth about her sister's fate, navigating a labyrinth of secrets, fears, and the unexplained as the shadows of their shared past begin to emerge.

As Mia delves deeper into her sister’s mysterious disappearance, she stumbles upon a series of unsettling leads that suggest the existence of a dark supernatural legacy long connected to their lives. The investigation soon spirals into uncharted territory, revealing a surreptitious evil that dates back to their childhood. The revelations not only test Mia's strength and resilience but also challenge the very foundation of what she thought she understood about her sister, themselves, and the paranormal world they once explored together. Each revelation becomes more terrifying than the last, as the stakes build and the shadows of the unknown loom larger.

Robert, played by Brendan Sexton III, joins Mia on her quest, bringing with him a blend of skepticism and expertise that complicates their dynamics. Together, they confront the unsettling truths buried in Shelby Oaks, where the line between reality and the supernatural begins to blur. As the pair unravels the enigma surrounding Riley's disappearance, they are forced to confront not only the malevolent forces at play but also their personal demons. The gripping tension and emotional depth of the narrative culminate in a chilling exploration of loyalty, loss, and the haunting legacy left behind by those who mysteriously vanish. With a compelling storyline and unforgettable characters, "Shelby Oaks" promises to keep viewers on the edge of their seats.

Critics' Reviews

“Shelby Oaks” opens promisingly, sketching through what looks like interview segments for a documentary and news clips about the disappearance of a YouTube star (a kinda funny meta choice given how much Stuckmann grew his base in that realm) named Riley Brennan (Sarah Dunn). She was the face of a group of ghost hunters called the “Paranormal Paranoids,” a controversial bunch who created online debate over whether or not their impressive videos were real. How could they be? There must be something else going on in the shots of figures in doorways. Stuckmann flirts with but doesn’t commit to an interesting subplot about disbelieving what we’re seeing and how sometimes we should trust the image.

Full review

With its pseudo-documentary opening, Shelby Oaks brings us up to speed on the disappearance of Riley Brennan (Sarah Durn), a member of a YouTube group called Paranormal Paranoids who have taken it upon themselves to explore unexplained hauntings… until they suddenly vanish in the titular abandoned town, leaving Mia (Camille Sullivan), Riley’s sister, to pick up the pieces. It’s through this documentary style that the film really gets its hooks into you. Not only does Stuckmann capture the nostalgia of the late-2000s era of YouTube with a near-perfect recreation of channel formats — from over-the-top presenting to volatile comments sections — but as the opening progresses, it becomes increasingly unsettling. Stuckmann thrives in this format, holding shots for long periods and replaying clips that reveal new haunting images. Yes, we’ve seen these moves before — in films like Lake Mungo or Willow Creek — but when they’re played this well, it’s easy to buy into the mystery of it all.

Full review

Main Cast of Shelby Oaks

Camille Sullivan

Mia

Brendan Sexton III

Robert

Crew of Shelby Oaks

Full backstage crew list →