Putzel was released to a modest reception, with critics appreciating its quirky humor and urban charm, though it did not achieve significant commercial success initially. Ashley Austin Morris and Fran Kranz were praised for their nuanced portrayals of Naomi and Salmon Guy, adding depth to the ensemble. Over time, Putzel has developed a dedicated fan base who admire its character-driven storytelling and witty dialogue. Today, it is often regarded as an underrated gem — a heartfelt and clever series that deserves more recognition for its unique take on family dynamics and romantic complications within the close-knit Upper West Side community.