After the breakout success of the song "I Can Only Imagine," MercyMe's Bart Millard is living the dream—sold-out arenas, a devoted fan base, and a thriving career. But behind the spotlight, Bart's past threatens the family he's built, especially the fragile bond with his son, Sam. When hopeful newcomer Tim Timmons joins the band for their biggest tour yet, he unknowingly brings a renewed gratitude to Bart's life through their unlikely friendship. Bart soon discovers that Tim carries hardships—and secrets—of his own, forcing him to face his past and repair his relationships with Sam and his wife, Shannon, before fame costs him what matters most.
Critics' Reviews
70
This sequel picks up after that happy ending to ask, “Is there life after the happily ever after, when it all gets hard again, and the pain never goes away?” Broadway musical star John Michael Finley returns as Bart, now married to Shannon (Sophie Skelton, taking over from Madeline Carroll). They have young children, and he is torn about leaving the family behind when his band goes on tour. Their oldest son, Sam, asks, “Why do you always have to miss the good stuff?” On tour, Bart gets a frantic phone call. Sam is in the hospital. He is diagnosed with juvenile diabetes, which means constant monitoring.
Full Cast of I Can Only Imagine 2
Arielle Kebbel
Hilary Timmons
In 'I Can Only Imagine 2,' Arielle Kebbel delivers a heartfelt and compelling performance as Hilary Timmons, effectively portraying the emotional depth and resilience of her character. Her nuanced acting brings a genuine warmth and authenticity to the film, distinguishing this role from her earlier performances in genres such as horror and romantic comedy where she often portrayed more lighthearted or suspense-driven characters. A notable trivia fact is that Kebbel took on this role partly due to her admiration for faith-based projects, finding a personal connection that influenced her sincere portrayal.
Joshua Bassett
Christopher
In 'I Can Only Imagine 2,' Joshua Bassett delivers a heartfelt and nuanced portrayal of Christopher, bringing depth and authenticity to his character's journey. His performance marks a notable evolution from his previous roles, such as his breakout part in 'High School Musical: The Musical: The Series,' showcasing his versatility and ability to handle more dramatic material. A trivia fact: Joshua Bassett is also a talented singer-songwriter, and his musical background subtly enhances his screen presence, adding an extra layer of emotional resonance to his performance in this inspiring film.
Trace Adkins
Scott Brickell
Fans of Trace Adkins will appreciate his role in 'I Can Only Imagine 2' because it showcases his deep, resonant voice and authentic presence, much like his iconic country music performances that have endeared him to audiences. While his music often conveys heartfelt storytelling through song, this film performance allows him to bring raw emotion and sincerity to a cinematic narrative, deepening his connection with fans. An interesting and unexpected detail is that Trace Adkins was initially considered for a different role but impressed the casting team so much during auditions that the filmmakers created a new character tailored specifically for him, highlighting his unique talents and personality.
Milo Ventimiglia
Tim Timmons
In 'I Can Only Imagine 2,' Milo Ventimiglia delivers a heartfelt and nuanced performance as Tim Timmons, capturing the emotional struggles and redemption arc of the character with sincerity and depth. Compared to his roles in series like 'This Is Us,' where he portrays Jack Pearson with warmth and complexity, Ventimiglia brings a similarly authentic and grounded presence to Tim Timmons, showcasing his range in portraying emotionally charged characters. A trivia fact: Milo Ventimiglia initially auditioned for the role of Jack Pearson in 'This Is Us' without expecting it to become a defining role in his career.
- Released February 19, 2026