Carlito's Way was released in 1993 and initially received mixed reviews. While critics praised Al Pacino's compelling portrayal of Carlito Brigante and the stylish direction by Brian De Palma, some felt the film's plot was somewhat predictable. Sean Penn's performance as the corrupt lawyer David Kleinfeld also garnered attention. Over time, however, Carlito's Way has gained significant appreciation from both fans and critics alike, evolving into a cult classic. It is now regarded as an underrated gem within the crime drama genre, celebrated for its strong performances, atmospheric storytelling, and its nuanced portrayal of loyalty and redemption. The film's reputation has grown steadily, distancing it from its early mixed reception to become a beloved staple in Al Pacino's filmography and 1990s cinema.