
Another Cinderella Story, released in 2008 as a direct-to-DVD teen romantic comedy musical, initially received mixed to negative reviews. Critics often noted its predictable plot and derivative nature, viewing it as a modern retelling of the Cinderella fairy tale with contemporary pop culture elements. Featuring Selena Gomez as Mary Santiago and Lynda Boyd as Evie Parker, the film was appreciated by younger audiences for its catchy music and dance sequences but criticized for its clichéd storyline.
Over time, the film has gained a modest following, particularly among fans of early 2000s teen movies and dance musicals. While it is not widely recognized as a cult classic, some viewers consider it an underrated gem within its niche. Its reputation now balances between nostalgic appreciation for its charm and acknowledgement of its dated aspects, with most agreeing it captures the spirit of its era without significant lasting impact.