
"A Simple Wish" was released in 1997 and initially received mixed to negative reviews from critics, who found its plot somewhat predictable and its humor uneven. The film starred Martin Short as Murray, a male fairy godmother, and Kathleen Turner as the antagonist Claudia. Despite a family-friendly premise and a whimsical tone, it failed to make a significant impact at the box office and was often overshadowed by other fantasy comedies of the time.
Over the years, however, "A Simple Wish" has gained a modest following. Many viewers appreciate its quirky charm, the performances of Short and Turner, and its nostalgic 90s feel. While it is not widely considered a major cult classic, the film has been regarded by some as an underrated gem that delivers light-hearted family entertainment. Its reputation has improved with nostalgia, though elements such as special effects and certain plot points now feel somewhat dated to contemporary audiences.